A Revisit: Graphic Novels

A Revisit: Graphic Novels

By Gabrielle Darling



This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Graphic novels are both an art and literary form. The only words they use to tell the story are through dialogue and internal thoughts. This should limit their ability to tell a story, but in actuality it has allowed for the art to take over building characters, worlds, and story almost entirely. This is no small feat to incorporate two wildly differing skills into one successful book, which is why I’ve listed three graphic novels that utilize both skills to create something different. I’d recommend any of the three to an aspiring artist or writer in order to expand their way of thinking as they both write and draw to become a part of their perspective fields.

The first is underground comic Bone by Jeff Smith. Originally published in 1991 it has been re-released in 2005 to make nine concise issues. This graphic novel follows three characters, Fone Bone, Smiley Bone, and Phoney Bone as they unknowingly make their way into a hidden valley and awaken an evil older than the earth. With their newfound allies – Thorn, Grandma Ben, Lucius, and the Great Red Dragon they must save the valley and the spirit world from the evil known as the Locust.

This colorful cast of characters is each portrayed in a different cartoon style. From the extremely realistic, to caricature, and finally the very basic cartoon all of the characters fit into the world around them.

Despite the vast differences in appearance cartoonist Jeff Smith has successfully created a world and a story capable of combining various cartoon styles into an epic saga. Saga is the correct word as the books display a varying degree of darkness and uncertainty as the Locust draws closer. The once playful cartoons and carefree characters take on new roles and responsibilities, which change our perception of their form based on posture, action, and movement.

Although in later editions there are some plot holes and the pacing picks up without character development the series is entertaining. As a writer it is important to experience multiple forms of writing and I recommend choosing this graphic novel as your first introduction.

The second graphic novel is an anthology series by Kazu Kibuishi who wrote the award winning Amulet series. After his success he chose to develop a graphic novel where several writers could submit a short flash-fiction style piece based around a loose theme. His Explorer series ends with the third and final The Hidden Doors. Within the graphic novel are multiple writers and artists who have created stories circling the themes of doors as portals to different choices, adventures, and amazing worlds. His theme throughout the trilogy has been to take ordinary objects such as boxes and islands and try to spin a story out of an ordinary object.

The series is very successful and allows for many different stories to come of one simple object. This freedom also allows the artists to draw in the style that best suits their story to lend power to the subtle choice of words.

Some of the notable stories within the graphic novel are The Giant’s Kitchen by Jason Caffoe and Mastaba by Johane Matte. Both are noted cartoonists who have published in previous anthologies. If you enjoy flash-fiction you’ll enjoy the quick glimpse of worlds and stories this graphic novel has to offer.


The final graphic novel is Girl Genius by Phil and Kaja Foglio. This graphic novel was created in 2000 and has since become a weekly web comic rather than a quarterly publishing.

Girl Genius boasts a strong female lead and the catchphrase “Adventure, Romance, & Mad Science”. Although some would argue its steampunk nature, it has actually become it’s own sub genre known as “Gaslamp Fantasy” as it incorporates elements of various scientific fields rather than just focusing on engineering and alchemy as most steampunk themes are wont to do.

The story focuses on Agatha Clay – a young lab assistant who lacks “the spark” so many in Europa are born with. “The spark” gives individuals in Europa the ability to create monstrosities and marvels of science, unfortunately without the ability to control most of their inventions. This has lead to chaos within the land of Europa only to be brought to general order by the overlord Baron Klaus Wulfenbach. Yet, Agatha Clay is not all she seems and soon the question of her family line brings trouble far and wide as she wades through lies and secrets in an attempt to find her own “spark”.

If you enjoy humor and adventure this is the graphic novel for you. There are times of tenseness and danger, but every character has their sense of humor and it shines through even when the world is darkest.

The art borders on the realistic side and shows mood and tone through color alongside the action of their characters. Setting is an important theme throughout the series and I recommend reading them for any aspiring writers.

Graphic novels are under heavy debate for their merits and flaws in the educational, written, and even artistic world, but when two art forms are brought together there is something for everyone on to learn and I recommend checking them out. The stories alone are well worth the time and effort, but the additional artwork may just inspire your own stories.

Art by: Jeff Smith, Kazu Kibuishi, Jason Caffoe, and Phil Foglio


Gabrielle Darling is a bookworm and dog-lover. She has published one non-fiction piece and continues to develop her skills because there’s no better pastime than writing.


One thought on “A Revisit: Graphic Novels

Add yours

  1. You cover a lot in this review! I was especially interested in how you explored elements of visual art, such as the style of Jeff Smith’s different characters. This could be tricky to convey through written analysis, but you successfully described the images.

    This post is more than long enough for the initial blog post requirement. If you polish this for the final post, though, I encourage further development. Since you mention the strength of both the writing and the visual art, it would be good to get a couple more quotes into the review (perhaps a quote that shows Agatha Clay’s humor? or a quote from one of the excerpts you recommend from _Hidden Doors_). You also might include a couple specifics for the color and setting used in _Girl Genius_. As the review expands, it might be helpful to divide it into sections, with headings that frame each of the graphic novels you discuss.

    Based on your comments, I think I’d really like _Hidden Doors_!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: